1. Welcome to The Prosecutors

Hello everyone. It’s Brett and Alice, and we are so glad to have you along this crazy ride with us. We’re going to be talking about some of the most famous cold cases of all time, bringing our experience as prosecutors to bear on our favorite mysteries. We hope this website can become a repository of information on these cases, and any public documents we use or cite we will try to link here both to credit the authors and to give you access to them. The more eyes on these cases, the better. But before we do that, we wanted to introduce ourselves to all of you.

In this episode, we tell a little bit about ourselves, and we set out the rules we are going to do our best to stick to during our investigation. Here they are, our ten commandments of sorts.

  1. The simplest answer is the most likely to be correct.
  2. If there is no evidence of a crime, there probably wasn’t a crime.
  3. Usually, law enforcement can be trusted.
  4. Conspiracies are hard to pull off and even harder to keep secret.
  5. Do not mistake incompetence for malice.
  6. There will never be a theory that answers all the questions or addresses all the evidence.
  7. We never know all the facts.
  8. The most obvious suspect is usually the one who did it.
  9. People lie, but that doesn’t make them liars.
  10. BUT in extraordinary cases, expect the extraordinary. Cause what’s the point of rules if you can’t break them?

Legal Briefs 05. Adnan Syed and Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

We continue our look at ineffective assistance of counsel through the lens of the Adnan Syed case. Check it out here on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.


Lower Court Opinion Granting Relief for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

Opinion Reversing Lower Court Ruling

138. The Trial of Casey Anthony Part 1 of 6 — White Lies, Blue Eyes

She was dubbed the most hated mother in America. But did Casey Anthony get away with murder?



Butcher Box: butcherbox.com/PROSECUTE for a free grilling bundle

Tivic Health Clear Up: tivichealth.com promo code: prosecutors22

Final Days on Earth Podcast

Progressive Insurance

Call Me Curious Podcast


137. The Ghost Ship Orang Medan — Flying Dutchman

Ships respond to a distress call from another vessel only to find everyone on board dead. Or did they?

The Dutch Translations:

English Newspaper story from 1940



  • Faherty: fahertybrand.com/tp code: TP for 20% off
  • Upside: Download the app and use promo code prosecute for $5 or more cash back
  • Hello Fresh: hellofresh.com/tp16 code: tp16
  • The Jordan Harbinger Show
  • Tivic ClearUp: tivichealth.com promo code prosecutors22
  • Progressive Insurance
  • PlutoTV
  • Final Days on Earth Podcast

Legal Briefs 03. The Lawyer Dog

Did a man really miss out on a lawyer because he asked for a “lawyer, dog” instead of just asking for a “lawyer”? And we read an insightful email on the Dammion Heard case. For more on the need to clearly invoke your right to a lawyer, read Davis v. United States, which held:

We decline petitioner’s invitation to extend Edwards and require law enforcement officers to cease questioning immediately upon the making of an ambiguous or equivocal reference to an attorney… [W]e held in Miranda that a suspect is entitled to the assistance of counsel during custodial interrogation even though the Constitution does not provide for such assistance. We held in Edwards that, if the suspect invokes the right to counsel at any time, the police must immediately cease questioning him until an attorney is present. But we are unwilling to create a third layer of prophylaxis to prevent police questioning when the suspect might want a lawyer. Unless the suspect actually requests an attorney, questioning may continue.


136. The Murder of Maggie Long — Have You Talked to the Man Upstairs?

Seventeen-year-old Maggie Long was the light of her community, but that light was snuffed out in what may have been a hate crime. Or was something else going on?



Progressive Insurance

Credit Karma: creditkarma.com/loanoffers

June’s Journey

Tivic ClearUp: tivichealth.com promo code: prosecutors22

The Jordan Harbinger Show: jordanharbinger.com/subscribe

Final Days on Earth Podcast

Legal Briefs — 01. Johnny Depp and Amber Heard: Dead Men Tell No Tales

It’s the defamation trial of the century, Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard. We talk about the legal standard for defamation, what’s really going on here, and who we think is going to win (and our reaction to the answer). We also talk about the difference between civil and criminal juries and why this case was brought in Virginia.

Find it here on Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts (once the various providers activate the feed, which may take some time).

134. The Disappearance of Daniel Robinson Part 1 of 2 — The Painted Desert

A promising young geologist disappears into the Arizona desert. Where is Daniel Robinson?

Daniel is described as a 5’8 black man, weighing 165 pounds with black hair, brown eyes and is missing part of his right forearm, including his hand. A $10,000 reward is being offered by Daniel’s family for information that can bring him home. If you have any information, go to pleasehelpfinddaniel.com or call a tip line at 844-602-0660.



Butcher Box: butcherbox.com/PROSECUTE for a free grilling bundle

Progressive Insurance

Final Days on Earth